YouTube’s New Comments Design: A Copy of Reddit or a Step Forward?

• YouTube introduces a new threaded comments UI similar to Reddit for Android and iOS users.
• The new design visually connects profile images to main comments but lacks full threading.
• Users have mixed reactions, with some finding it useful and others seeing it as unnecessary.

YouTube has been refining its comment section on mobile apps to enhance user engagement and simplify discussions. Over time, AI-driven features like comment topics and live chat summaries have gained traction, improving the overall experience. Now, YouTube has unveiled a redesigned comment interface that adopts a Reddit-inspired threaded layout.

The new threaded comments UI on YouTube’s Android and iOS apps introduces a visual connector linking the profile picture of the original commenter with their replies. This update aims to make discussions more structured and engaging. However, unlike Reddit’s fully branched threading system, YouTube’s version does not extend the indicator to subsequent replies. This limitation means users must still rely on username tags to determine whether a response is to the main comment or a reply within the thread.

Instagram Teen Accounts India Safer Social Media with Parent Control

YouTube New Comments Design: Inspired by Reddit?

While YouTube’s new comment system borrows elements from Reddit, it retains some distinct differences. Unlike Reddit, where replies are displayed in a fully expanded format, YouTube keeps responses condensed by default. This approach allows users to skip unnecessary threads and focus only on relevant conversations. However, some users feel that the update does little to improve readability or engagement, making it an unwelcome change.

Discussions on Reddit reveal a divided opinion among users. Some appreciate the structured look, while others criticize its lack of true threading. Many believe that if YouTube intends to mimic Reddit’s format, it should fully implement threaded conversations to enhance clarity and usability.

Pros and Cons of YouTube’s New Comments UI

Pros:

WhatsApp Status Update Tools A Game-Changer for Quick Sharing

• Provides a cleaner, more organized comment structure.
• Helps users visually connect main comments with replies.
• Prevents excessive scrolling by keeping replies condensed.

Cons:

• Lacks full threading like Reddit, making conversations harder to follow.
• Users still need to check username tags for context.
• Some find the change unnecessary without significant usability improvements.

User Reactions and Feedback

Since its rollout, the updated comment interface has sparked debates among YouTube users. Some believe it enhances the discussion experience, while others find it confusing or unnecessary. Many have voiced their opinions on social media, questioning whether the redesign truly benefits users or simply imitates Reddit without fully committing to its structure.

YouTube has yet to confirm whether additional refinements will be made based on feedback. As users continue to adapt, the platform may consider improvements to address concerns and enhance readability further.

YouTube’s attempt to introduce a new threaded comments UI has sparked mixed reactions among users. While the visual indicator helps structure discussions, the lack of complete threading leaves room for improvement. Whether this change enhances the commenting experience or adds unnecessary complexity remains a topic of debate. As YouTube continues to experiment, user feedback will likely shape future refinements.